The 9th of Rabi al-Awwal is a festival of the Ahl al-Bayt (as), known as the Joy of al-Zahra (as). Is the joy over the appointment of Imam al-Mahdi (atfs), or over something else?
Answer
After the Shia became able to openly practice their rites in both times of mourning and times of rejoicing, they began to manifest joy on the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal, regarding it as one of the festivals. This festival came to be known among them as the Joy of al-Zahra (as).
The reason for taking the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal as a festival is hidden from many people. It appears that the concealment of the reason is due to a matter that required dissimulation (taqiyyah) and conciliation (mudarat).
Some have considered that the assumption of the outward Imamate by Imam al-Hujjah (atfs), on the second day after the martyrdom of his father, Imam al-Askari (as), is the reason for taking the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal as a festival. This view does not withstand criticism for the following reasons.
Why the appointment is not the cause of the festival
The claim that the reason for celebrating the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal is the appointment of Imam al-Hujjah (atfs), despite the fact that we have found no narrational evidence for this, entails that the Shia themselves instituted it without proof. This cannot be accepted because taking a particular day as a festival and performing certain recommended practices on it, such as ritual washing, requires religious legislation. The Shia, especially their scholars, cannot practice without a textual basis.
It is not appropriate for a community that believes its Imams are the vicegerents of Allah on His earth to take, without narrational evidence, the second day after the departure of the preceding Imam as a festival rejoicing at the Imamate of the succeeding one. This is especially so when the predecessor is the father of the successor and was killed by poison before reaching the age of thirty. Moreover, there is no reason for the succeeding Imam himself to rejoice, because rejoicing at that would include rejoicing at the departure of his father. If the succeeding Imam has no reason to rejoice, why should his Shia rejoice?
It might be said that, since the succeeding Imam is the savior of humanity who will fill the earth with equity and justice as it was filled with oppression and injustice, it is legitimate for the community to rejoice at his assumption of the outward Imamate. The reply is that, if this were valid, rejoicing would be valid after the death of every Imam at the appointment of the one who follows him, on the grounds that every time an Imam departs, the community draws nearer to the era of the Savior (atfs).
It is well known among the Shia that the Imams were appointed by Allah before the creation of the world. The succeeding Imam is only permitted to assume the burdens of the outward Imamate after the departure of his predecessor. Accordingly, there is no new appointment or coronation involved. Even the Festival of Ghadir was not an appointment that established the Imamate of Ameerul Momineen (as). Rather, it was a manifestation of his Imamate and of the Imamate of the Imams from his progeny, and the establishment of the proof against the community.
Those who say that the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal is a joy over the appointment did not rely on any narrational report. They offered it as an interpretive justification for the actual practice of the Shia in taking the 9th as a festival and performing certain recommended acts on it. The one who holds this view either did not notice or did not rely upon the narration that explicitly states another reason, namely, the narration of Ahmad ibn Ishaq al-Qummi.
If what is meant by appointment is the assumption of the burdens of the outward Imamate, that occurred in the very moment the preceding Imam departed this world, on the 8th, not the 9th. If what is meant is celebrating that event, this is not among the ethics of the infallible Imams or their Shia.
It might be asked how the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal can be taken as a festival when Imam al-Askari (as) was martyred on the 8th. Imam al-Askari (as) was martyred on the 8th of Rabi al-Awwal in 260 AH, but the Shia did not begin taking the 9th as a festival in that same year. According to the narration, the Ahl al-Bayt (as) had regarded the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal as a festival since the time of the Prophet (saws) because of their knowledge of its special status, even if they did not make it public to the generality of the Shia for a beneficial reason.
Eid al-Fitr remains the first of Shawwal every year, including after the year in which Ameerul Momineen (as) was martyred eight or nine days before Eid. In the year of his martyrdom, the Shia did not celebrate that Eid joyfully out of mourning for their Imam, but this changed in the following years.
- We seek an excuse for those who said it was over the appointment, whether out of dissimulation, conciliation, or oversight. The conclusion, however, is that appointment cannot be accepted as the reason for taking the 9th of Rabi al-Awwal as a festival. There must be another reason.
We know of no reason that has reached us from the Pure Ones (as) except the destruction of their bitterest enemy, which is what the narration of Ahmad ibn Ishaq al-Qummi from Imam al-Hadi (as) explicitly states. That narration includes several recommended practices, among them the removal of black clothing and ritual washing, concerning which a number of jurists have issued rulings either as recommended or in hope of reward.
And praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds.