Upon reviewing texts regarding Ameerul Momineen (as), it becomes evident that those living alongside him have often been a victim of bias. Despite witnessing the lofty status of Ameerul Momineen (as), the Ahle Tasannun did not accept his leadership and guidance; instead, they resorted to false allegations against him and those close to him. One prominent example is the noble personality of Hazrat Abu Talib (as). For example, Dhahabi has criticized Nisaai, who is the author of one of the four most popular books of the Ahle Tasannun for his love of Ameerul Momineen (as).
Why do some from the Ahle Tasannun claim that Hazrat Abu Talib (as) was not a believer? The answer is as clear as daylight. There are numerous reasons for this false allegation, primarily stemming from jealousy and hatred towards Ameerul Momineen (as). From the inception of Islam, Imam Ali (as) was consistently the first to respond and assist the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny) in every task, which did not go unnoticed by the hypocrites who held grudges against him since the day of Dawat-e-Zul Asheera. For example, Tabari tried to change his record of Dawat-e-Zul Asheera to hide the excellences of Ameerul Momineen (as).
Additionally, Ameerul Momineen (as) killed many hypocrites in battlefields, further aggravating their animosity. These hypocrites, who never wanted Islam to flourish, saw their plans thwarted by the relentless efforts of the Ahlul Bayt (as). Following the martyrdom of the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny), these hypocrites rebelled, oppressing the Ahlul Bayt (as) through false allegations, defamation, social boycotts, and killings.
One significant reason for the baseless claims about Hazrat Abu Talib’s (as) faith is his relationship with Imam Ali (as) and his lifelong service to the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny) and Islam. To the extent that Bukhari, despite his extreme bias against the Ahlul Bait (as), has recorded a tradition from Abbas (the uncle of the Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny)) that speaks about the sacrifices of Hazrat Abu Talib (as) for the Prophet (peace be upon him and his holy progeny) – Refer: Bukhari Tradition No: 6208.
Similarly, they even raised false allegations on the faith of Ameerul Momineen (as), despite acknowledging him as one of the four rightly guided caliphs.
As documented by Shaikh al-Saduq (ar) in Elal al-Sharaye, “Ali ibn Hathram said: I was in the assembly of Ahmad ibn Hanbal when the mention of Ali ibn Abi Talib, peace be upon him, came up, and he said: “A man cannot be a Sunni until he dislikes Ali (as) a little…”
Reference
- Elal al-Sharaye, volume 2, page 468, tradition no. 65
Ibn Abi al-Hadid, the famed Motazali scholar, has discussed this in his book “Sharh Nahjul Balaghah,” wherein he has brought an entire chapter titled “Al Hadeesul Mauzuato Fi Zammi Ali (as)” which translates to “The Fabricated Traditions in Condemnation of Amirul Momineen Ali ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon them both).”
One such narration from Zohri goes like this:
“And Abd al-Razzaq narrated from Ma'mar that al-Zohri had two narrations from Urwah about Aisha regarding Ali (as), so he asked him about them one day. He said: “What do you want to do with them? God knows best about them. I indeed accuse them (Urwah and Aisha) of bias towards the Bani Hashim.”
He said: “As for the first hadith, we have mentioned it. As for the second hadith, it is that Urwah claimed that Aisha narrated to him that she said: ‘I was with the Prophet when al-Abbas and Ali (as) came in. He said: ‘O Aisha, if you wish to look at two men of the Hellfire, then look at these two who have just entered.’ So, I looked, and it was al-Abbas and Ali ibn Abi Talib!!’ [God forbid]”
Reference
- Sharh Nahjul Balagah, Ibn Abil Hadeed, vol 4 page 64
Another narration about Hazrat Abu Talib (as) is quoted by Amr ibn Aas, an advisor to Muawiya.
“And a hadith is narrated from him that is narrated by al-Bukhari and Muslim in their Sahihs with a connected chain of transmission to Amr ibn al-Aas, who said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (as) say: ‘The progeny of Abu so-and-so (referring to Hazrat Abu Talib (as)) are not my guardians; rather, my guardians are Allah and the righteous believers.'”
Reference
- Sharh Nahjul Balagah, Ibn Abil Hadeed, vol 4 page 64, Bukhari tradition no. 5990, Muslim, tradition no. 215
These traditions clearly showcase the hatred towards the Ahlul Bayt (as), particularly Ameerul Momineen (as) and his father, Hazrat Abu Talib (as).
It is worth questioning whether such allegations would be directed towards their self-appointed caliphs. In reality, their own caliphs committed numerous oppressions and frequently transgressed religious boundaries. To obscure their faults, they attempt to defame Hazrat Abu Talib (as) and his immaculate progeny (as).
By closely examining these narratives through Quranic verses and the teachings of Ahlul Bayt (as), we find numerous narrations that speak about the pure belief and righteousness of Hazrat Abu Talib (as).
It is crucial to approach these historical accounts with a discerning eye and an open heart to uncover the true legacy of this esteemed figure in Islamic history. May Allah grant us the intercession of this great personality of Islam.